The debate between carpet and hardwood floors is a common one in the flooring industry, with various opinions and viewpoints. However, certain qualities and characteristics can assist homeowners in making an informed decision. Factors such as upfront and long-term costs, maintenance, durability, and resale value are important considerations when comparing hardwood and carpet floors.
When it comes to cost, hardwood flooring is generally more expensive than carpet. The installation cost of hardwood can range from $12 to $20 per square foot, while carpet installation typically costs between $6 and $12 per square foot. However, engineered hardwood flooring can be a more affordable option than solid hardwood, with a price range of $7 to $15 per square foot for a quality product.
CARPET VS HARDWOOD FLOORS
The choice between hardwood and carpet flooring depends on the homeowner’s preferences, the project, and the size of the home. Some homeowners opt for a combination of both types of flooring in different rooms. While good quality carpet can last up to 10 to 15 years, hardwood flooring can withstand more wear and tear and spills without requiring replacement. In fact, well-maintained hardwood floors can last a lifetime. Thus, the long-term cost of hardwood flooring may offer greater value and eliminate the hassle of replacing worn-out carpet in the future.
When it comes to resale value, hardwood flooring is the clear winner in the carpet vs hardwood debate. A study by USA Today revealed that 54% of home buyers are willing to pay more for a home with hardwood floors. HGTV also noted that hardwood floors are the top request of home buyers and renters. Hardwood floors have a direct impact on a home’s value, and this trend is expected to continue as the popularity of hardwood flooring remains high.
In terms of maintenance, hardwood floors are easier to clean and maintain than carpet. Dust, spills, surface stains, and other debris can be swept or damp mopped from hardwood floors. Using quality mops and Bona® Hardwood Floor Cleaner products is recommended as they are effective, sustainably developed, and aligned with LIFECORE®’s healthy hardwood flooring standards.
Carpet
Carpet, on the other hand, traps dust, dirt, and allergens in its fibers over time, making it difficult to maintain its pristine appearance. Regular vacuuming is necessary to remove these particles, but deep shampoo cleaning or special treatments may be required for stubborn stains. While some types of pretreated and synthetic fiber carpets are designed to resist stains, hardwood flooring is generally easier to maintain in the long run.
When considering the impact on home health and the environment, natural carpets like wool are a better choice compared to synthetic carpets. Wool and other natural fibers are renewable, and they break down easily without polluting the environment. On the other hand, synthetic carpets made with petroleum are non-renewable and release harmful VOCs over time.
Hardwood floorin
Hardwood flooring is a renewable material, especially if harvested and planted responsibly. With low-VOC options like LIFECORE products, homeowners can choose healthy, kid and pet-friendly flooring that contains no harsh chemicals. Hardwood floors are durable and can last up to 100 years with proper maintenance, while carpets typically only last 5 to 15 years depending on the quality.
Ultimately, the decision between carpet and hardwood floors is a matter of preference. While some may prefer the comfort and insulation of carpet in bedrooms, hardwood floors are a better choice for overall cost, maintenance, durability, and home health. Carpets can exacerbate the presence of allergens in the bedroom, making hardwood flooring the winning choice.
